Origins, Ontology & Metaphysics
48 entries · AI-assisted research
A. The Existence and Nature of Allah
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhat Is Allah? The Ontological QuestionWhat does it mean for Allah to exist? Do the Quran and classical theology describe Allah as a being, an essence, or as beyond created categories—and how does 'what Allah is' differ from 'who Allah is'?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceAllah's Essence (Dhāt)What is meant by Allah's essence (dhāt) in Islamic theology, how does it relate to the attributes (ṣifāt), and can it be comprehended?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceDoes Allah Have a Form or Body?How should Quranic and hadith descriptions of God's hands, face and eyes be understood: literal affirmation, figurative interpretation, or affirmation without modality?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceIs Allah Inside or Outside Creation?How do Quran 20:5 ('the Beneficent established on the Throne') and 57:4 ('He is with you wherever you are') fit together, and can spatial language apply to an uncreated being?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceDoes Allah Exist in Time or Beyond Time?Is God's eternity timelessness or endless duration, did time begin with creation, and how can a timeless God act in succession?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceAllah's Knowledge Before CreationDoes God know all things before they occur, and does foreknowledge cause or determine events?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceAllah's Will and Divine AgencyWhat is God's will (irāda/mashī'a), how does it relate to creation, and does divine action imply change in God?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
B. Before Creation and the Beginning of Existence
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhat Existed Before Creation?What do the hadith say existed 'before' creation, how do the variants of Bukhari 3191 differ, and does 'before' have meaning prior to time?Quran IndirectHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhat Was the First Thing Allah Created?Which was created first—the Pen, the Throne, or water—and how do the narrations compare?Quran IndirectHadith ExplicitHadith Authentication⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe Throne of Allah (Al-'Arsh)What does the Quran say about God's Throne, was it created, and how have theologians interpreted God's 'establishment' upon it?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe Kursi: Throne or Footstool?What is the Kursi of 2:255, and is it the same as the 'Arsh?Quran ExplicitClassical TafsirLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe Preserved Tablet (Al-Lawḥ al-Maḥfūẓ)What is the Preserved Tablet, how does it relate to God's knowledge, and is it created?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe Pen and the Writing of DestinyWhat is the Pen (al-qalam), is it a created instrument, and what was written 50,000 years before the heavens and the earth?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitHadith Authentication⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceDid Allah Create Time?What do the Quran's 'six days' mean, is time created, and how reliable is the hadith listing what was created on each weekday?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceCreation From Nothing: Ex NihiloDoes the Quran teach creation from nothing, and how does it compare with Genesis 1:1 and John 1:3?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit
D. Angels, Jinn, Iblis, and the Unseen World
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhat Are Angels Made Of?Does the Quran say what angels are made of, or does the 'created from light' teaching come from hadith?Quran ExplicitHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhat Are Jinn Made Of?What does the Quran say about the creation of jinn, and how do jinn compare with humans?Quran ExplicitHadith Explicit
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWas Iblis an Angel or a Jinn?How do 2:34 and 18:50 bear on whether Iblis was an angel or a jinn?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectClassical Tafsir⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhy Was Iblis Among the Angels?Does the Quran explain why Iblis was present when the angels were commanded, and where do the narratives about his former status come from?Classical TafsirLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceDid Iblis Have Free Will?Do 7:11–18 and 18:50 present Iblis as a free, accountable agent?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectClassical Tafsir⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe Refusal to Bow Before AdamWhat is Iblis' argument in 7:12 and 38:76, and how have Muslims and Christians interpreted rebellion?Quran ExplicitClassical Tafsir⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWas Iblis in Paradise Before His Fall?Was the garden of Adam—and of Iblis' expulsion—the heavenly Paradise or an earthly garden?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceSatan, Iblis, and the Devil: Are They the Same?How does Quranic terminology distinguish Iblis from shayṭān/shayāṭīn, and how does it compare with biblical Satan?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceJinn Possession and Spiritual InfluenceDoes the Quran or hadith teach jinn possession, and how should such claims be evaluated?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe Qarin: The Companion JinnWhat is the qarīn in the Quran and in Muslim 2814, and does it remove human free will?Quran ExplicitHadith Explicit
E. Human Creation, Soul, and Consciousness
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe Creation of AdamHow do Quran 2:30–39, 15:26–29 and 38:71–72 describe Adam's creation, and how do they compare with Genesis 1–2?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitClassical Tafsir
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhat Is the Rūḥ (Spirit)?What does 17:85 say about the rūḥ, and how is the human spirit distinguished from Gabriel or revelation?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceRūḥ vs. Nafs: Spirit and SoulHow do the Quranic terms rūḥ and nafs relate, and how do classical Islamic and Christian anthropologies compare?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceDid Souls Exist Before Bodies?Does Quran 7:172 (the covenant 'Am I not your Lord?') teach pre-existent souls?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceAdam's Knowledge of the NamesWhat were 'the names' taught to Adam (2:31–33), and what does the episode say about human and angelic knowledge?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitClassical Tafsir
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe First Sin: Adam vs. IblisHow does the Quran compare Adam's disobedience with Iblis' rebellion, and how do Islamic and Christian understandings of the Fall differ?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
F. Metaphysical and Philosophical Questions
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceNecessary Existence, Contingency, and the CreatorWhat are the Avicennian argument from contingency and the kalam argument from temporal origination, and how do they relate to Quranic teaching?Quran IndirectLater Theology or PhilosophyChristian Comparison
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceCan an Eternal Being Interact With a Temporal World?Does divine action imply change in God, and how do Islamic and Christian theologies relate eternal will to temporal effects?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
Qadar: The Four Stages of Divine Predestination
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceStage 1 — Al-'Ilm (Knowledge)What is the first stage of qadar, what Quranic and hadith evidence supports it, and how do Sunni, Mu'tazili and Shi'i views differ?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceStage 2 — Al-Kitābah (Writing)What is the stage of 'writing', and what was written, when and where?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceStage 3 — Al-Mashī'ah (Will)What does the stage of divine will assert, and how is human will related to it?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceStage 4 — Al-Khalq (Creation)Does God create human actions, and how is human responsibility maintained?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
Qadar: Types and Levels of Divine Decree
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceTypes and Levels of Divine DecreeWhich levels of decree are stated in the texts and which are later classifications?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitHadith Authentication⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceIf Allah Has Already Decreed Everything, What Can Be Erased or Changed? (Quran 13:39)What does 'Allah effaceth what He will, and establisheth, and with Him is the source of ordinance' (13:39) mean, and can prayer, charity or kinship ties change destiny?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
Abrogation (Naskh) and Divine Knowledge
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceWhat Is Naskh? Quran 2:106, 16:101 and Replaced RulingsWhat is naskh, what do 2:106 and 16:101 say, which verses are classically held to replace earlier rulings, and how does abrogation differ from clarification and specification?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceAbrogation of Recitation vs. Ruling, and Reports of Withdrawn RevelationWhat are the three classical types of abrogation, and what do the reports of forgotten or withdrawn revelation say?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceDoes Abrogation Imply Allah Changed His Mind?Does abrogation imply new knowledge in God, can eternal knowledge allow successive revelation, and how can an eternal Quran contain changing rulings?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectHadith Explicit⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceHow Does Abrogation Relate to the Preserved Tablet?Is abrogation a change in the Preserved Tablet, and how does it differ from changes in recorded decrees?Quran ExplicitQuran IndirectClassical Tafsir
The Metaphysics of Allah's Names
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceThe 99 Names: The Authentic Hadith and the Circulated ListsWhat is authentically established about God's 99 names, and how reliable is the commonly circulated list?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitHadith Authentication⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceAre Allah's Names Created or Uncreated? Are They Identical to His Essence or Distinct From the Attributes?Are God's names created or uncreated, identical to His essence, or distinct from His attributes?Quran ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceRelational Names Before Creation: Creator, Merciful and Loving (al-Wadūd) Before There Were CreaturesWas God 'Creator', 'Merciful' and 'Loving' before anything existed, and does divine love require an eternal object?Quran ExplicitHadith ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceDo Divine Actions Imply Change in Allah? Eternal Speech Through Created SoundsDo divine actions imply change in God, and can eternal speech be expressed through created sounds?Quran ExplicitLater Theology or Philosophy⚑ requires further research
- Cross-worldview / Philosophy & EvidenceHow Athari, Ash'ari, Maturidi, Mu'tazili and Christian Theologians Approach the NamesHow do the major schools approach divine names and attributes, keeping each school's teaching separate from critics' objections?Quran ExplicitLater Theology or PhilosophyChristian Comparison
Also part of this collection
These topics are covered by entries published in other folders.
- Can Allah's Attributes Exist Independently?→ Can God's Attributes Act Independently?
- Can Allah's Attributes Exist Independently?→ Athari, Ash'ari and Maturidi Views of the Divine Attributes
- Can Allah's Attributes Exist Independently?→ Allah's Essence (Dhāt)
- Is Allah's Speech Eternal?→ Allah's Eternal Speech (Kalām)
- Is Allah's Speech Eternal?→ Is the Quran Created or Uncreated?
- How Does an Uncreated Being Speak?→ Allah's Eternal Speech (Kalām)
- How Does an Uncreated Being Speak?→ How Did Allah Speak Before Creation?
- How Does an Uncreated Being Speak?→ Quran 42:51: How Allah Communicates
- How Did Gabriel Receive the Quran?→ How Did Gabriel Receive the Quran?
- How Did Gabriel Receive the Quran?→ Gabriel's Role in Revelation
- How Did Gabriel Receive the Quran?→ Direct vs. Mediated Revelation
- The Command "Be" (Kun Fayakun)→ 'Be, and It Is' (Kun Fayakūn)
- Can Allah's Speech Act Independently?→ Can God's Attributes Act Independently?
- Can Allah's Speech Act Independently?→ The Quran's Intercession
- Can Allah's Speech Act Independently?→ The Eternal Word: Jesus and the Quran Compared
- Allah Breathing "My Spirit" Into Adam→ 'I Breathed into Him of My Spirit' (Rūḥī)
- Allah Breathing "My Spirit" Into Adam→ What Is the Rūḥ (Spirit)?
