NewImproved Live Rooms and a community Forum are here.Live Rooms and Forum
Live RoomsForumDeveloper update: Our Apple and Android apps are coming soon. In the meantime, you can install The Apologetics Network on your phone or computer right now.
Welcome to The Apologetics Network, an educational platform dedicated to Christian apologetics, biblical studies, comparative religion, theology, philosophy, and historical research.
The information provided on this website is intended for educational, informational, and research purposes.
Content may include theological interpretations, historical arguments, religious comparisons, artificial intelligence-generated explanations, and differing religious viewpoints.
We encourage visitors to independently evaluate information, examine original sources, and approach religious discussions with intellectual honesty and respect.
AI-generated content may contain inaccuracies, omissions, or interpretations requiring independent verification.
By continuing, you acknowledge the educational nature of this platform and agree to comply with our Terms and Conditions and applicable responsible-use standards.
“Continue browsing” records nothing; we’ll ask again next visit.
Primary Source · Brahma Sutra 2.1 (Thibaut)
Thibaut’s English rendering of the sūtras, SBE 34 (1890). Cite as Brahma Sutra 2.1.1 (Thibaut). The commentary of Śaṅkara is Advaita Vedanta and is not hosted in full on this page.
If it be objected that (from the doctrine expounded hitherto) there would result the fault of there being no room for (certain) Smritis; we do not admit that objection, because (from the rejection of our doctrine) there would result the fault of want of room for other Smritis.
And on account of the non-perception of the others (i.e. the effects of the pradhana, according to the Saṅkhya system).
Thereby the Yoga (Smriti) is refuted.
(Brahman can) not (be the cause of the world) on account of the difference of character of that, (viz. the world); and its being such, (i.e. different from Brahman) (we learn) from Scripture.
But (there takes place) denotation of the superintending (deities), on account of the difference and the connexion.
But it is seen.
If (it is said that the effect is) non-existent (before its origination); we do not allow that because it is a mere negation (without an object).
On account of such consequences at the time of reabsorption (the doctrine maintained hitherto) is objectionable.
Not so; as there are parallel instances.
And because the objections (raised by the Saṅkhya against the Vedanta doctrine) apply to his view also.
If it be said that, in consequence of the ill-foundedness of reasoning, we must frame our conclusions otherwise; (we reply that) thus also there would result non-release.
Thereby those (theories) also which are not accepted by competent persons are explained.
If it be said that from the circumstance of (the objects of enjoyment) passing over into the enjoyer (and vice versa) there would result non-distinction (of the two); we reply that (such distinction) may exist (nevertheless), as ordinary experience shows.
The non-difference of them (i.e. of cause and effect) results from such terms as 'origin' and the like.
And because only on the existence (of the cause) (the effect) is observed.
And on account of that which is posterior (i.e. the effect) being that which is.
If it be said that on account of being denoted as that which is not (the effect does) not (exist before it is actually produced); (we reply) not so, (because the term 'that which is not' denotes) another quality (merely); (as appears) from the complementary sentence.
From reasoning and from another Vedic passage.
And like a piece of cloth.
And as in the case of the different vital airs.
On account of the other (i.e. the individual soul) being designated (as non-different from Brahman) there would attach (to Brahman) various faults, as, for instance, not doing what is beneficial.
But the separate (Brahman, i.e. the Brahman separate from the individual souls) (is the creator); (the existence of which separate Brahman we learn) from the declaration of difference.
And because the case is analogous to that of stones, &c. (the objections raised) cannot be established.
If you object on the ground of the observation of the employment (of instruments); (we say), No; because as milk (transforms itself, so Brahman does).
And (the case of Brahman is) like that of gods and other beings in ordinary experience.
Either the consequence of the entire (Brahman undergoing change) has to be accepted, or else a violation of the texts declaring Brahman to be without parts.
But (this is not so), on account of scriptural passages, and on account of (Brahman) resting on Scripture (only).
For thus it is in the (individual) Self also, and various (creations exist in gods[305], &c.).
And because the objection (raised against our view) lies against his (the opponent's) view likewise.
And (the highest divinity is) endowed with all (powers) because that is seen (from Scripture).
If it be said that (Brahman is devoid of powers) on account of the absence of organs; (we reply that) this has been explained (before).
(Brahman is) not (the creator of the world), on account of (beings engaging in any action) having a motive.
But (Brahman's creative activity) is mere sport, such as we see in ordinary life.
Inequality (of dispensation) and cruelty (the Lord can) not (be reproached with), on account of his regarding (merit and demerit); for so (Scripture) declares.
If it be objected that it (viz. the Lord's having regard to merit and demerit) is impossible on account of the non-distinction (of merit and demerit, previous to the first creation); we refute the objection on the ground of (the world) being without a beginning.
(The beginninglessness of the world) recommends itself to reason and is seen (from Scripture).
And because all the qualities (required in the cause of the world) are present (in Brahman).