E. Muhammad, Aisha, and Women in Early Islam
Women Captives and Concubinage (mā malakat aymānukum)
What do 4:24, 23:5–6 and 33:50 say, what does mā malakat aymānukum mean, and how should historical doctrines be distinguished from modern ethics?
- Quran
- 23:5–6; 4:24; 33:50
- Hadith
- Bukhari 2229, 4138; Abu Dawud 2157
- Explicit in Quran
- Yes
- Mainly hadith
- No
- Authenticity
- Quranic; hadith sahih.
- Christian question
- Was consent required?
- Muslim response
- Regulated and abolished; impermissible today.
AI-assisted summary
Classical law permitted concubinage with captives after a waiting period.
- Explicitly stated in the Quran
- Explicitly stated in Hadith
- Classical Tafsir interpretation
- Later Islamic jurisprudence
- Contemporary scholarly interpretation
