F. Christianity, Islam, and Western Government
Can Islamic Law and Western Constitutional Principles Be Reconciled?
Where are Islamic law and Western constitutionalism compatible, and where do they conflict?
- Quran
- 42:38; 4:58
- Hadith
- Muslim 1733
- Explicit in Quran
- No
- Mainly hadith
- No
- Authenticity
- —
- Classical
- Sharia supremacy.
- Contemporary
- Reform; overlapping consensus.
- Constitutional
- First/Fourteenth Amendments.
- Disagreements
- Supremacy.
- Christian question
- Can Muslims accept the U.S. Constitution?
- Muslim response
- Citizenship compatible.
AI-assisted summary
Compatible in many areas; conflicts in classical penal and status law.
