AI-assisted researchPrimary-source quotations are pulled verbatim from the library's licensed texts.
Requires further research
- European survey data requires further research.
3 claims are marked in the text below with a requires further research or “requires verification” badge. Treat them as unverified.
Source classification
- Contemporary Empirical Evidence
- Pew 2017 (U.S.); Pew 2013 (39 countries).
Research question
What do credible, dated surveys show about Muslims' attitudes toward democracy, sharia, religious freedom and civic participation—and what are their limits?
Overview
Pew Research Center's 2017 survey of U.S. Muslims (1,001 adults, 23 Jan–2 May 2017) found: 65% see no natural conflict between Islam and democracy (30% see a conflict); 92% are proud to be American; 76% say targeting civilians is never justified (U.S. public: 59%); 82% are concerned about extremism in the name of Islam worldwide; 64% say there is more than one true way to interpret Islam; 52% say traditional understandings need reinterpretation. Pew's 2013 global survey (more than 38,000 interviews in 39 countries, 2008–2012) found support for making sharia official law ranged from 8% (Azerbaijan) and 10% (Kazakhstan) to 99% (Afghanistan), with regional medians from 12% (Central Asia) to 84% (South Asia), and that many supporters wanted it applied only to Muslims; it did not survey Western Europe. Comparable, current, verified figures for European Muslims are not included here: requires further research. Surveys describe attitudes; they do not define what Islam teaches, and extremist groups or selected individuals must not be taken as representative.
Quran
Descriptive entry; no Quranic claim is made.
Hadith
Descriptive entry.
Original language
—
Tafsir
—
Theology
—
Christian comparison
Christian apologists should cite data accurately and distinguish beliefs of Muslims from claims about Islamic law.
Philosophy
Muslims cite the data as evidence of civic integration and opposition to extremism.
Critical examination
Established
- Figures above are quoted from Pew's published reports, with dates and samples.
Disputed
- How question wording on 'sharia' is understood.
- Generalising from one country to 'the West'.
Assessment
Data show wide diversity; U.S. Muslims largely affirm democracy and reject violence; global sharia support varies hugely by country and is often limited to Muslims.
Discussion questions
- What do the samples cover and not cover?
- How might 'sharia' be understood by respondents?
- Why not generalise from extremists?
Survey and empirical data
Fieldwork 23 Jan – 2 May 2017 · Representative sample of 1,001 Muslim adults in the U.S., landline and cellphone
Limits: United States only; telephone survey; self-report (Pew notes voting is overreported); the Islam–democracy question is a single item; does not measure attitudes in Europe.
Pew Research Center, 'The World's Muslims: Religion, Politics and Society' (published 30 Apr 2013)
Fieldwork 2008–2009 (15 sub-Saharan countries) and 2011–2012 (24 countries/territories); published 30 Apr 2013 · More than 38,000 face-to-face interviews with Muslims in 39 countries, 80+ languages
Limits: Covers Muslim-majority and some minority countries in six regions; does not cover Western Europe or North America (U.S. compared via a separate 2011 survey); omits Algeria, China, India, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria among large Muslim populations (per the report); results are regional medians and vary greatly by country; question wording on 'sharia' may be understood differently by respondents.
Surveys of Muslims in Western Europe (attitudes toward democracy and sharia)
Limits: requires further research: no current, verified, dated survey has been added yet.
Scholars and works cited
No scholars are named in this entry.
Linked names are in the About the scholars registry.
