NewImproved Live Rooms and a community Forum are here.Live Rooms and Forum
Live RoomsForumDeveloper update: Our Apple and Android apps are coming soon. In the meantime, you can install The Apologetics Network on your phone or computer right now.
Welcome to The Apologetics Network, an educational platform dedicated to Christian apologetics, biblical studies, comparative religion, theology, philosophy, and historical research.
The information provided on this website is intended for educational, informational, and research purposes.
Content may include theological interpretations, historical arguments, religious comparisons, artificial intelligence-generated explanations, and differing religious viewpoints.
We encourage visitors to independently evaluate information, examine original sources, and approach religious discussions with intellectual honesty and respect.
AI-generated content may contain inaccuracies, omissions, or interpretations requiring independent verification.
By continuing, you acknowledge the educational nature of this platform and agree to comply with our Terms and Conditions and applicable responsible-use standards.
“Continue browsing” records nothing; we’ll ask again next visit.
Primary Source · Brahma Sutra 1.2 (Thibaut)
Thibaut’s English rendering of the sūtras, SBE 34 (1890). Cite as Brahma Sutra 1.2.1 (Thibaut). The commentary of Śaṅkara is Advaita Vedanta and is not hosted in full on this page.
(That which consists of mind is Brahman) because there is taught what is known from everywhere.
And because the qualities desired to be expressed are possible (in Brahman; therefore the passage refers to Brahman).
On the other hand, as (those qualities) are not possible (in it), the embodied (soul is) not (denoted by manomaya, &c.).
And because there is a (separate) denotation of the object of activity and of the agent.
On account of the difference of words.
And on account of Smriti.
If it be said that (the passage does) not (refer to Brahman) on account of the smallness of the abode (mentioned), and on account of the denotations of that (i.e. of minuteness); we say, no; because (Brahman) has thus to be contemplated, and because the case is analogous to that of ether.
If it is said that (from the circumstance of Brahman and the individual soul being one) there follows fruition (on the part of Brahman); we say, no; on account of the difference of nature (of the two).
The eater (is the highest Self) since what is movable and what is immovable is mentioned (as his food).
And on account of the topic under discussion. That the highest Self only can be the eater referred to is moreover evident from the passage (Ka. Up. I, 2, 18), ('The knowing Self is not born, it dies not'), which shows that the highest Self is the general topic. And to adhere to the general topic is the proper proceeding. Further, the clause, 'Who then knows where he is,' shows that the cognition is connected with difficulties; which circumstance again points to the highest Self.
The 'two entered into the cave' (are the individual soul and the highest Self), for the two are (intelligent) Selfs (and therefore of the same nature), as it is seen (that numerals denote beings of the same nature).
And on account of the distinctive qualities (mentioned).
The person within (the eye) (is Brahman) on account of the agreement (of the attributes of that person with the nature of Brahman).
And on account of the statement of place, and so on.
And on account of the passage referring to that which is distinguished by pleasure (i.e. Brahman).
And on account of the statement of the way of him who has heard the Upanishads.
(The person within the eye is the highest), not any other Self; on account of the non-permanency (of the other Selfs) and on account of the impossibility (of the qualities of the person in the eye being ascribed to the other Selfs).
The internal ruler over the devas and so on (is Brahman), because the attributes of that (Brahman) are designated.
And (the internal ruler is) not that which the Smriti assumes, (viz. the pradhana,) on account of the statement of qualities not belonging to it.
And the embodied soul (also cannot be understood by the internal ruler), for both also (i.e. both recensions of the Brihad Aranyaka) speak of it as different (from the internal ruler).
That which possesses the attributes of invisibility and so on (is Brahman), on account of the declaration of attributes.
The two others (i.e. the individual soul and the pradhana) are not (the source of all beings) because there are stated distinctive attributes and difference.
And on account of its form being mentioned.
Vaisvanara (is the highest Lord) on account of the distinction qualifying the common terms (Vaisvanara and Self).
(And) because that which is stated by Smriti (i.e. the shape of the highest Lord as described by Smriti) is an inference (i.e. an indicatory mark from which we infer the meaning of Sruti).
If it be maintained that (Vaisvanara is) not (the highest Lord) on account of the term (viz. Vaisvanara, having a settled different meaning), &c., and on account of his abiding within (which is a characteristic of the gastric fire); (we say) no, on account of the perception (of the highest Lord), being taught thus (viz. in the gastric fire), and on account of the impossibility (of the heavenly world, &c. being the head, &c. of the gastric fire), and because they (the Vajasaneyins) read of him (viz. the Vaisvanara) as man (which term cannot apply to the gastric fire).
For the same reasons (the Vaisvanara) cannot be the divinity (of fire), or the element (of fire).
Jaimini (declares that there is) no contradiction even on the assumption of a direct (worship of the highest Lord as Vaisvanara).
On account of the manifestation, so Asmarathya opines.
On account of remembrance; so Badari opines.
On the ground of imaginative identification (the highest Lord may be called pradesamatra), Jaimini thinks; for thus (Scripture) declares.
Moreover they (the Jabalas) speak of him (the highest Lord) in that (i.e. the interstice between the top of the head and the chin which is measured by a span).