Philosophy & Evidence Mind and Consciousness
Mind and Consciousness
Can consciousness be placed in a wholly natural world, and what do religious views of the self claim?
AI-assisted researchStatus: PublishedReview: Not reviewed by a person
Written 19 November 2026. This page has not been reviewed by a person.
Introduction
The nature of consciousness is a live dispute in philosophy of mind. Some philosophers argue that subjective experience is difficult to explain in wholly physical terms; others defend physicalist or naturalist accounts. Religious traditions add claims about the soul, atman, or (in Buddhism) the absence of a permanent self. Those religious claims are not settled by a single neuroscience headline, and a scientific result is not automatically a proof of atman or of no-self. Keep the questions distinct, and use scholarly overviews rather than slogans. Open the linked entry for the full argument, objections, and citations. This site does not copy those articles.
Religious perspectives
Attributed to the tradition or school named, not to “religion” in general.
Abrahamic theism
Jewish, Christian, and Muslim writers have often held that a human being is more than a body, though they disagree about the soul, resurrection, and the intermediate state. Some contemporary theists also engage philosophy of mind directly (for example, on whether consciousness fits a physicalist picture).
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Consciousness (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Scripture Library (Bible and Qur’an readers on this site) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Hinduism · Vedanta and related schools
Many Hindu schools discuss atman (the self) and its relation to Brahman. Advaita and Dvaita disagree about whether the self is ultimately identical with Brahman. That debate is not the same as the contemporary “hard problem of consciousness,” even when later writers connect them.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Hinduism (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Advaita Vedānta (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Buddhism
Buddhist analysis of mind typically denies a permanent self (anatta) and describes experience as conditioned and impermanent. That is a different teaching from Vedanta and from Abrahamic soul doctrines.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Buddha (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- SuttaCentral (external) — Pali Canon and translations; licences vary by translator (known license, to confirm).
Nonreligious perspectives
Atheism is not a religion. Positions are named separately.
Naturalism and physicalism
Physicalists hold that the mind is not a separate substance and that conscious states are, or depend on, physical states. Dualists and some other critics argue that experience is not captured by that picture. The dispute is ongoing. It does not, by itself, prove or disprove God.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Consciousness (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Naturalism (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Arguments and counterarguments
Objections are stated because they matter, not because every view is equally supported.
The place of experience
Arguments from consciousness to God, or to dualism, start from the claim that experience is not explained by physical theory. They need a further step to reach theism. Read a careful overview before treating them as a proof.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Consciousness (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Physicalist and Buddhist replies
Physicalists offer identity, functional, or other accounts of consciousness and challenge the inference to a soul or to God. Buddhist philosophers offer a different analysis of mind without a permanent self. These replies also have objections.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Consciousness (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Buddha (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Naturalism (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Related in the research library
Discuss this
Members 16+ can take this question into a live room or start a forum thread. Guests can read the forum. These links go to the live rooms and the forum; they do not open a real, pre-created thread about this hub.
Live roomsDiscuss this · Philosophy & EthicsDiscuss this · Science & ReligionForum
Further reading
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Consciousness (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Advaita Vedānta (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Buddha (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
