The Apologetics Network
Support

NewImproved Live Rooms and a community Forum are here.Live Rooms and Forum

Live RoomsForum
Cross-worldview / Philosophy & Evidence

The Substitution Theory: Was Someone Else Crucified?

substitution · shubbiha · Judas · docetism · Basilides · Gospel of Barnabas

AI-assisted researchPrimary-source quotations are pulled verbatim from the library's licensed texts.

Requires further research

1 claim is marked in the text below with a requires further research or “requires verification” badge. Treat it as unverified.

Source classification

No source classification was assigned to this entry in its package. Source types it cites: quran, history, historical text.

Research question

What are the substitution interpretations of Quran 4:157, where do they come from, how do Muslim scholars disagree about them, and what evidence supports each interpretation?

Overview

The 'substitution theory' is the view that God cast Jesus' likeness onto another person, who was crucified in his place, while Jesus was raised to heaven. It is the most common traditional Muslim reading of 4:157, but the Quran does not name a substitute, and exegetes proposed different candidates. Earlier, some 2nd-century Christian-era groups (later called docetists and Gnostics) also denied that Jesus truly suffered, and the Christian writer Irenaeus reports that the teacher Basilides claimed Simon of Cyrene was crucified in Jesus' place.

Background

Classical tafsir records several versions: (1) a volunteer disciple who accepted Jesus' likeness in exchange for paradise; (2) Judas or another betrayer, punished by being made to look like Jesus; (3) a Roman or Jewish guard. Al-Tabari reports multiple versions with chains to early figures such as Wahb ibn Munabbih and Qatada (requires further research on each chain). Some exegetes, such as al-Razi, discussed objections: if God can make one person look like another, sense perception and the transmission of all reports—including reports about prophets—become uncertain. The so-called 'Gospel of Barnabas', which makes Judas the substitute, survives in Italian and Spanish manuscripts from the late medieval period and is regarded by scholars, including many Muslim scholars, as a late composition, not an early Gospel. Irenaeus' report on Basilides (Against Heresies 1.24.4) is quoted below.

Primary sources

وَقَوْلِهِمْ إِنَّا قَتَلْنَا ٱلْمَسِيحَ عِيسَى ٱبْنَ مَرْيَمَ رَسُولَ ٱللَّهِ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ وَمَا صَلَبُوهُ وَلَٰكِن شُبِّهَ لَهُمْ وَإِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ ٱخْتَلَفُوا۟ فِيهِ لَفِى شَكٍّ مِّنْهُ مَا لَهُم بِهِۦ مِنْ عِلْمٍ إِلَّا ٱتِّبَاعَ ٱلظَّنِّ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ يَقِينًۢا ﴿4:157﴾

Tanzil Uthmani 1.1 (CC BY 3.0, verbatim; https://tanzil.net)

4:157And because of their saying: We slew the Messiah, Jesus son of Mary, Allah's messenger - they slew him not nor crucified him, but it appeared so unto them; and lo! those who disagree concerning it are in doubt thereof; they have no knowledge thereof save pursuit of a conjecture; they slew him not for certain.

M. M. Pickthall, The Meaning of the Glorious Koran (1930), public domain

[Primary / public domain] Hosted on this site.

Stop your ears, therefore, when any one speaks to you at variance with Jesus Christ, who was descended from David, and was also of Mary; who was truly born, and did eat and drink. He was truly persecuted under Pontius Pilate; He was truly crucified, and [truly] died, in the sight of beings in heaven, and on earth, and under the earth. He was also truly raised from the dead, His Father quickening Him, even as after the same manner His Father will so raise up us who believe in Him by Christ Jesus, apart from whom we do not possess the true life.

Translator: Alexander Roberts, James Donaldson, Frederick Crombie (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1870)

Public domain (Project Gutenberg text in the library). Bracketed footnote numbers removed; plain inline note numerals in the Whiston text are left as printed and are not part of the source

Ignatius of Antioch (c. 110 CE), shorter recension, insists that Jesus 'was truly crucified, and [truly] died' — evidence that 'appearance-only' views were already circulating and opposed.

[Primary / public domain] Hosted on this site.

But if, as some that are without God, that is, the unbelieving, say, that He only seemed to suffer (they themselves only seeming to exist), then why am I in bonds? Why do I long to be exposed to the wild beasts? Do I therefore die in vain? Am I not then guilty of falsehood against [the cross of] the Lord?

Translator: Alexander Roberts, James Donaldson, Frederick Crombie (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1870)

Public domain (Project Gutenberg text in the library). Bracketed footnote numbers removed; plain inline note numerals in the Whiston text are left as printed and are not part of the source

Ignatius, To the Trallians 10 (shorter recension): against those who say Jesus 'only seemed to suffer'.

[Primary / public domain] Hosted on this site.

Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.24.4 (c. 180 CE), describing the teaching of Basilides (ANCL tr.; Wikisource)

historical text
Wherefore he did not himself suffer death, but Simon, a certain man of Cyrene, being compelled, bore the cross in his stead; so that this latter being transfigured by him, that he might be thought to be Jesus, was crucified, through ignorance and error, while Jesus himself received the form of Simon, and, standing by, laughed at them.

Public-domain 19th-century translation; digital text from English Wikisource (CC BY-SA 4.0) · source

Irenaeus reports (and rejects) a 2nd-century Gnostic teaching that Simon of Cyrene was crucified in Jesus' place. This is the earliest known substitution account; it comes from a Gnostic cosmology very different from the Quran's.

[Primary / public domain] Accessed 17 November 2026.

Original language

See the 4:157 entry for shubbiha. The docetic opponents in Ignatius are described with the Greek verb dokein ('to seem'), from which 'docetism' is named; the ANCL English renders it 'only seemed to suffer'. The Quranic shubbiha (resemblance) and the Greek dokein (seeming) are different words in different languages; any historical link between the docetic tradition and the Quranic verse is a scholarly hypothesis, not a demonstrated dependence.

Christian perspective

Christian apologists raise several objections: (1) no 1st-century source suggests a substitute; the earliest denials of Jesus' suffering are 2nd-century docetic teachings already opposed by Ignatius; (2) substitution would mean God deceived Jesus' mother, disciples and enemies, and Christianity's founding belief would rest on a divinely caused error; (3) the variety of substitute candidates in tafsir suggests speculation rather than transmitted knowledge; (4) the 'Gospel of Barnabas' is late and contains anachronisms.

Islamic perspective

Muslim scholars respond that the Quran is the decisive revelation and does not need historical corroboration; human witnesses can be mistaken, and the verse itself says they followed conjecture. Divine rescue of a prophet from enemies has Quranic precedent (e.g. Abraham from the fire, 21:69). Many Muslim scholars hold that the exact mechanism is not specified and need not be known; the essential claim is that Jesus was not killed or crucified and was raised. Some, following al-Razi's caution, prefer not to commit to a particular substitute narrative. A number of modern Muslim scholars also reject the Gospel of Barnabas as inauthentic and do not rely on it.

Critical examination

Established

  • The Quran denies the killing and crucifixion but names no substitute.
  • Substitute narratives vary in classical tafsir.
  • Christian sources from c. 110 CE already oppose claims that Jesus only seemed to suffer.

Disputed

  • The origin and chains of the classical substitution reports.
  • Whether docetic or Gnostic ideas influenced later Muslim exegesis.
  • Whether substitution is required by 4:157 or only one possible reading.

Assessment

Substitution is a theological interpretation with no independent historical attestation; its strength depends entirely on the authority one gives to the Quran. Christians and Muslims can agree that the historical record does not contain a substitute account from the 1st century.

Open questions

  • Verify al-Tabari's chains for the substitution reports from a primary edition.

Discussion questions

  • Why might exegetes have proposed different substitutes?
  • Does a divinely caused illusion raise problems for trusting any historical testimony?
  • What is the significance of Ignatius already opposing 'seeming' views around 110 CE?
  • Is the Gospel of Barnabas useful evidence for either side?

Scholars and works cited

  • al-Tabari, d. 310 AH / 923 CE, Sunni exegete, historian and jurist (Baghdad)

Further reading (as cited in the entry)

  • [Academic] al-Tabari (d. 310/923), Jami' al-Bayan (tafsir) on the verses cited.
  • [Academic] Fakhr al-Din al-Razi (d. 606/1210), Mafatih al-Ghayb (al-Tafsir al-Kabir) on the verses cited.
  • [Academic] Todd Lawson, The Crucifixion and the Qur'an: A Study in the History of Muslim Thought (Oxford: Oneworld, 2009).
  • [Academic] Gabriel Said Reynolds, 'The Muslim Jesus: Dead or Alive?' Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 72 (2009). Accessed 17 November 2026. doi.org (opens another site)
  • [Academic] Neal Robinson, Christ in Islam and Christianity (Albany: SUNY Press, 1991). Accessed 17 November 2026. doi.org (opens another site)
  • [Academic] Oddbjørn Leirvik, Images of Jesus Christ in Islam (2nd ed., London: Continuum, 2010).

Linked names are in the About the scholars registry.

Related entries

Developer update: Our Apple and Android apps are coming soon. In the meantime, you can install The Apologetics Network on your phone or computer right now.