Philosophy & Evidence The Problem of Evil and Suffering
The Problem of Evil and Suffering
How does evil or suffering bear on belief in a God who is all-powerful and perfectly good?
AI-assisted researchStatus: PublishedReview: Not reviewed by a person
Written 19 November 2026. This page has not been reviewed by a person.
Introduction
The problem of evil is one of the most discussed challenges to classical theism. A logical version claims that the existence of any evil is inconsistent with an all-powerful, all-knowing, perfectly good God. An evidential version claims that the amount or kind of suffering we see makes that God unlikely. Responses (often called theodicies or defenses) offer reasons God might permit suffering, or argue that we are not in a position to judge. Other traditions discuss suffering without that classical theistic frame: Buddhism begins with dukkha; some Hindu schools discuss karma and liberation; some atheists treat suffering as what a natural world would lead us to expect. These are different projects and should be kept distinct. Open the linked entry for the full argument, objections, and citations. This site does not copy those articles.
Religious perspectives
Attributed to the tradition or school named, not to “religion” in general.
Abrahamic theism
Jewish, Christian, and Muslim writers have appealed to free will, to soul-making, to a greater divine plan, to the limits of human knowledge, or to a future restoration. No one reply is agreed by all theists. Scripture also contains laments and protests, not only explanations. Use the scripture library and the SEP entry rather than a single slogan.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Problem of Evil (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Scripture Library (Bible and Qur’an readers on this site) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Hinduism · school-dependent
Some Hindu accounts relate present suffering to karma and to a cycle of rebirth; theistic schools may also speak of the Lord’s justice or play (lila). Advaita treats ignorance and appearance as the deeper problem. These are not interchangeable with a Christian free-will theodicy.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Hinduism (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Advaita Vedānta (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Buddhism
The Four Noble Truths begin with suffering (dukkha), its arising, its ending, and the path. The framework is not usually an attempt to defend an all-powerful Creator. Compare it with theism only by naming both sides clearly.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Buddha (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- SuttaCentral (external) — Pali Canon and translations; licences vary by translator (known license, to confirm).
Nonreligious perspectives
Atheism is not a religion. Positions are named separately.
Atheism and naturalism
Many atheists argue that the scale of natural and moral suffering is more likely on a naturalistic picture than on classical theism. That is an evidential claim; it depends on what we should expect if God exists. Agnostics may treat the problem as unsettled. Follow the SEP entry for leading formulations.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Problem of Evil (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Atheism and Agnosticism (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Arguments and counterarguments
Objections are stated because they matter, not because every view is equally supported.
Logical and evidential problems
The logical problem asks whether God and any evil can both exist. The evidential problem asks whether the suffering we actually see is strong evidence against God. They need different replies. See the SEP entry for the distinction and for major defenses.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Problem of Evil (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Defenses and their limits
Free-will, soul-making, and skeptical-theism replies are widely discussed, and each has objections (the scope of natural evil, animal suffering, hiddenness, and whether a good God would use these means). Stating a defense is not the same as showing that it works. Read the arguments, not a verdict from this website.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Problem of Evil (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
Related in the research library
Discuss this
Members 16+ can take this question into a live room or start a forum thread. Guests can read the forum. These links go to the live rooms and the forum; they do not open a real, pre-created thread about this hub.
Live roomsDiscuss this · Theism vs NaturalismDiscuss this · Christianity vs AtheismForum
Further reading
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: The Problem of Evil (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Buddha (external) — link only; copyrighted or terms vary.
