F. Christianity, Islam, and Western Government
Christianity, Islam, and Religious Liberty
How do the two traditions' histories of coercion and tolerance compare, and what arguments for freedom of conscience exist?
- Quran
- 2:256; 18:29
- Hadith
- —
- Explicit in Quran
- Yes
- Mainly hadith
- No
- Authenticity
- Quranic.
- Classical
- Dhimma; apostasy law.
- Contemporary
- Reformist freedom of conscience.
- Constitutional
- First Amendment; UDHR Art. 18.
- Disagreements
- Apostasy.
- Christian question
- Which tradition supports liberty?
- Muslim response
- 2:256.
AI-assisted summary
Both traditions show coercion and liberty arguments.
