Summary
The Pearl of Great Price is the shortest of the four Latter-day Saint standard works. It contains selections from the Book of Moses, the Book of Abraham, Joseph Smith—Matthew, Joseph Smith—History and the Articles of Faith. It was first compiled in 1851 and canonized in 1880. Its Book of Abraham is at the center of a long debate about Egyptian papyri.
Official Latter-day Saint explanation (from the Church's Pearl of Great Price Introduction [1])
- Compilation. Elder Franklin D. Richards, then president of the British Mission, made the first collection in 1851. It was made a standard work by decision of the First Presidency and general conference on October 10, 1880.
- Revisions. Portions of Moses were added in 1878, duplicated material was removed in 1902, two revelations were added in 1976 and moved to the D&C (sections 137 and 138) in 1979.
- Contents:
- Selections from the Book of Moses: a portion of Genesis in Joseph Smith's translation of the Bible, begun June 1830.
- The Book of Abraham: which the Church presents as Joseph Smith's inspired rendering of writings by Abraham, begun in 1835 after Joseph Smith obtained Egyptian papyri. It was published in the Times and Seasons from March 1, 1842.
- Joseph Smith—Matthew: a portion of Joseph Smith's translation of Matthew.
- Joseph Smith—History: excerpts from his 1838–39 history, published from March 15, 1842.
- The Articles of Faith: published March 1, 1842, with the Wentworth Letter.
Primary texts
Moses 1:39; Abraham 3:22–23; Joseph Smith—History 1:17; Articles of Faith 1:1. Each opens on the official reader through this site's reference lookup [2].
Historical context: the Book of Abraham papyri
The Church's essay "Translation and Historicity of the Book of Abraham" [3] says:
- An entrepreneur, Michael Chandler, brought four mummies and papyrus scrolls to Kirtland, Ohio, in the summer of 1835.
- The papyri were sold in 1856, and most of them are thought to have burned in the 1871 Chicago fire.
- Ten fragments that had been in Joseph Smith's possession reached the Metropolitan Museum of Art, which transferred them to the Church in 1967.
- Egyptologists identify the surviving fragments as ordinary Egyptian funerary texts.
- The Egyptian grammar and alphabet documents associated with the project do not match modern Egyptology.
The essay offers more than one Latter-day Saint view of how the translation relates to the surviving fragments.
Independent scholarship
Peer-reviewed Egyptological and historical studies can be found through the BYU Religious Studies Center and Dialogue (see the source registry). None is cited here yet because none was checked against a copy.
Traditional Trinitarian Christian interpretation (Christian apologetic analysis, not the Church's position)
Christian critics argue that the papyri findings undermine the Book of Abraham's claim to be an ancient text. They also object to doctrines taught in it, such as premortal spirits and a plurality of divine beings in Abraham 3–5, as contrary to Isaiah 43:10 and 44:6. Latter-day Saint scholars respond with other models of translation. Present both sides fairly; do not state a conclusion as settled fact.
Areas of agreement
Both honor Abraham and Moses as prophets and value Genesis.
Areas of disagreement
They disagree on additional scripture, on premortal existence, and on the nature of Joseph Smith's "translation."
