The Apologetics Network
Support

NewImproved Live Rooms and a community Forum are here.Live Rooms and Forum

Live RoomsForum
Judaism · Pharisees

What Do Ancient Sources Say About the Pharisees?

AI-assisted researchStatus: PublishedReview: Not reviewed by a person

Links and attributed claims checked against the cited publisher pages on 17 November 2026. This entry has not been reviewed by a person.

Ancient evidence and later interpretation

This page distinguishes Second Temple sources from later commentary. Josephus and the New Testament are ancient, interested witnesses, not neutral modern histories. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica article is a later academic summary and is labelled as such [1]. Later rabbinic literature is also later than the Second Temple parties it discusses.

Second Temple setting and origins

In the 1911 Britannica account by J. H. A. Hart, the Pharisees are "a sect of the Jews first mentioned by Josephus, in his account (Ant. xiii. 5, 9) of the reign of Jonathan, the brother and successor of Judas Maccabaeus." The name, that article says, "may be translated 'Separatists'" [1]. Josephus's own narrative of the Jewish sects in the Second Temple period is hosted on this site in William Whiston's public-domain translation: Antiquities Book XVIII, chapter 1, and Wars Book II, chapter 8, "The Three Sects" [2][3]. Those chapters should be read in Josephus's wording rather than replaced by a paraphrase invented here.

Oral tradition and the law

The 1911 article states that when Alexandra came to the throne "the Pharisees were the real rulers and imposed upon the people the deductions from the written Law which formed the growing body of their oral tradition," and that this tradition became established "in respect of ritual" [1]. That is later historical interpretation of Josephus and other sources, not a Pharisee's own surviving handbook. For Josephus's language, use the hosted Antiquities and Wars sections already cited [2][3].

Resurrection and the afterlife

The New Testament, in the public-domain King James Version hosted on this site, associates Pharisees with belief in resurrection, in contrast to Sadducees: see Matthew 22:23, Mark 12:18, and Acts 23:6–8 [4][5][6]. Those are early Christian texts with their own aims. The 1911 article adds a later interpretive claim that Pharisees "deduced (for example) the doctrine of the resurrection of the dead from the death of the martyrs under Antiochus Epiphanes and Alcimus" [1]. That causal story is 1911 commentary; it is not quoted here as a Second Temple primary text.

Josephus and the New Testament as sources

Josephus wrote as a first-century Jewish historian with political and personal interests. The Gospels and Acts write as Christian scripture. Both remain indispensable ancient evidence for the names and disputes of Pharisees and Sadducees, and both must be read as interested sources [2][3][4][5][6].

Later rabbinic Judaism

The 1911 article connects Pharisaic oral tradition with what was "afterwards codified and elaborated or preserved by fragments… in the Talmud and other Rabbinic writings" (a remark made there in a discussion of Sadducean opposition) [1]. This page does not treat "the Pharisees became rabbinic Judaism" as a simple, settled fact. Later rabbinic texts look back on earlier sages and on oral Torah; that later literature is not a photograph of every Second Temple Pharisee. The relationship is a matter of historical debate and should be studied from the ancient sources and from modern scholarship, not from a slogan.

Questions for further study

  1. Read Josephus, Wars 2.8 and Antiquities 18.1, in the hosted Whiston text [2][3].
  2. Compare Acts 23:6–8 [6] with those Josephus chapters, noting what each author is trying to show.

Sources

  1. 1. [Academic / public domain] J. H. A. Hart, "Pharisees," Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th ed. (1911), via Wikisource. Origins in Josephus, Ant. xiii. 5, 9; "Separatists"; oral tradition under Alexandra; later interpretive remarks on resurrection and rabbinic writings. Accessed 17 November 2026. en.wikisource.org/wiki/1911_Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica/Pharisees (external)
  2. 2. [Primary / public domain] Flavius Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, Book XVIII, chapter 1, trans. William Whiston (1737), hosted on this site. Ancient description of the Jewish sects. theapologeticsnetwork.org/history/josephus-antiquities/231 (external)
  3. 3. [Primary / public domain] Flavius Josephus, The Wars of the Jews, Book II, chapter 8, "The Three Sects," trans. William Whiston (1737), hosted on this site. theapologeticsnetwork.org/history/josephus-wars/45 (external)
  4. 4. [Primary / public domain] Matthew 22:23, King James Version, hosted on this site. New Testament reference to Sadducees and resurrection, in a passage that also involves the Pharisees' dispute partners. theapologeticsnetwork.org/scripture/kjv/MAT/22#v23 (external)
  5. 5. [Primary / public domain] Mark 12:18, King James Version, hosted on this site. theapologeticsnetwork.org/scripture/kjv/MRK/12#v18 (external)
  6. 6. [Primary / public domain] Acts 23:6–8, King James Version, hosted on this site, on Pharisees, Sadducees and the resurrection. theapologeticsnetwork.org/scripture/kjv/ACT/23#v6 (external)

Official doctrinal texts are often copyrighted, and many publishers do not allow reposting, so this site summarises positions in its own words and links to the publisher's page for each point. Short official phrases, when quoted, are attributed and linked. These entries are AI-assisted research and have not been reviewed by a person.

Developer update: Our Apple and Android apps are coming soon. In the meantime, you can install The Apologetics Network on your phone or computer right now.