CHAPTER 10. That Whereas The City Of Jerusalem Had Been Five Times Taken Formerly, This Was The Second Time Of Its Desolation. A Brief Account Of Its History.
1. And thus was Jerusalem taken, in the second year of the reign of
Vespasian, on the eighth day of the month Gorpeius [Elul]. It had been
taken five 34 times before, though this was the second time of its
desolation; for Shishak, the king of Egypt, and after him Antiochus, and
after him Pompey, and after them Sosius and Herod, took the city, but
still preserved it; but before all these, the king of Babylon conquered
it, and made it desolate, one thousand four hundred and sixty-eight
years and six months after it was built. But he who first built it was
a potent man among the Canaanites, and is in our own tongue called
[Melchisedek], the Righteous King, for such he really was; on which
account he was [there] the first priest of God, and first built a temple
[there], 35 and called the city Jerusalem, which was formerly called
Salem. However, David, the king of the Jews, ejected the Canaanites,
and settled his own people therein. It was demolished entirely by the
Babylonians, four hundred and seventy-seven years and six months after
him. And from king David, who was the first of the Jews who reigned
therein, to this destruction under Titus, were one thousand one hundred
and seventy-nine years; but from its first building, till this last
destruction, were two thousand one hundred and seventy-seven years; yet
hath not its great antiquity, nor its vast riches, nor the diffusion
of its nation over all the habitable earth, nor the greatness of
the veneration paid to it on a religious account, been sufficient to
preserve it from being destroyed. And thus ended the siege of Jerusalem.
WAR BOOK 6 FOOTNOTES
1 (return) [ Reland notes here, very pertinently, that the tower of
Antonia stood higher than the floor of the temple or court adjoining
to it; and that accordingly they descended thence into the temple, as
Josephus elsewhere speaks also. See Book VI. ch. 2. sect. 5.]
2 (return) [ In this speech of Titus we may clearly see the notions
which the Romans then had of death, and of the happy state of those who
died bravely in war, and the contrary estate of those who died ignobly
in their beds by sickness. Reland here also produces two parallel
passages, the one out of Atonia Janus Marcellinus, concerning the Alani,
lib. 31, that "they judged that man happy who laid down his life in
battle;" the other of Valerius Maximus, lib. 11. ch. 6, who says, "that
the Cimbri and Celtiberi exulted for joy in the army, as being to go out
of the world gloriously and happily."]
3 (return) [ See the note on p. 809.]
4 (return) [ No wonder that this Julian, who had so many nails in his
shoes, slipped upon the pavement of the temple, which was smooth, and
laid with marble of different colors.]
5 (return) [ This was a remarkable day indeed, the seventeenth of
Panemuns. [Footnote Tamuz,] A.D. 70, when, according to Daniel's
prediction, six hundred and six years before, the Romans "in half a week
caused the sacrifice and oblation to cease," Daniel 9:27. For from the
month of February, A.D. 66, about which time Vespasian entered on this
war, to this very time, was just three years and a half. See Bishop
Lloyd's Tables of Chronology, published by Mr. Marshall, on this year.
Nor is it to be omitted, what year nearly confirms this duration of the
war, that four years before the war begun was somewhat above seven years
five months before the destruction of Jerusalem, ch. 5. sect. 3.]
6 (return) [ The same that in the New Testament is always so called, and
was then the common language of the Jews in Judea, which was the Syriac
dialect.]
7 (return) [ Our present copies of the Old Testament want this encomium
upon king Jechoniah or Jehoiachim, which it seems was in Josephus's
copy.]
8 (return) [ Of this oracle, see the note on B. IV. ch. 6. sect. 3.
Josephus, both here and in many places elsewhere, speaks so, that it is
most evident he was fully satisfied that God was on the Romans' side,
and made use of them now for the destruction of that wicked nation of
the Jews; which was for certain the true state of this matter, as the
prophet Daniel first, and our Savior himself afterwards, had clearly
foretold. See Lit. Accompl. of Proph. p. 64, etc.]
9 (return) [ Josephus had before told us, B. V. ch. 13. sect. 1, that
this fourth son of Matthias ran away to the Romans "before" his father's
and brethren's slaughter, and not "after" it, as here. The former
account is, in all probability, the truest; for had not that fourth
son escaped before the others were caught and put to death, he had been
caught and put to death with them. This last account, therefore, looks
like an instance of a small inadvertence of Josephus in the place before
us.]
10 (return) [ Of this partition-wall separating Jews and Gentiles, with
its pillars and inscription, see the description of the temples, ch.
15.]
11 (return) [ That these seditious Jews were the direct occasions
of their own destruction, and of the conflagration of their city and
temple, and that Titus earnestly and constantly labored to save both, is
here and every where most evident in Josephus.]
12 (return) [ Court of the Gentiles.]
13 (return) [ Court of Israel.]
14 (return) [ Of the court of the Gentiles.]
15 (return) [ What Josephus observes here, that no parallel examples
had been recorded before this time of such sieges, wherein mothers were
forced by extremity of famine to eat their own children, as had been
threatened to the Jews in the law of Moses, upon obstinate disobedience,
and more than once fulfilled, [see my Boyle's Lectures, p. 210-214,]
is by Dr. Hudson supposed to have had two or three parallel examples in
later ages. He might have had more examples, I suppose, of persons on
ship-board, or in a desert island, casting lots for each others' bodies;
but all this was only in cases where they knew of no possible way to
avoid death themselves but by killing and eating others. Whether such
examples come up to the present case may be doubted. The Romans were not
only willing, but very desirous, to grant those Jews in Jerusalem both
their lives and their liberties, and to save both their city and their
temple. But the zealots, the robbers, and the seditious would hearken to
no terms of submission. They voluntarily chose to reduce the citizens to
that extremity, as to force mothers to this unnatural barbarity, which,
in all its circumstances, has not, I still suppose, been hitherto
paralleled among the rest of mankind.]
16 (return) [ These steps to the altar of burnt-offering seem here
either an improper and inaccurate expression of Josephus, since it was
unlawful to make ladder steps; [see description of the temples, ch. 13.,
and note on Antiq. B. IV. ch. 8. sect. 5;] or else those steps or stairs
we now use were invented before the days of Herod the Great, and had
been here built by him; though the later Jews always deny it, and say
that even Herod's altar was ascended to by an acclivity only.]
17 (return) [ This Perea, if the word be not mistaken in the copies,
cannot well be that Perea which was beyond Jordan, whose mountains
were at a considerable distance from Jordan, and much too remote from
Jerusalem to join in this echo at the conflagration of the temple; but
Perea must be rather some mountains beyond the brook Cedron, as was the
Mount of Olives, or some others about such a distance from Jerusalem;
which observation is so obvious, that it is a wonder our commentators
here take no notice of it.]
18 (return) [ Reland I think here judges well, when he interprets these
spikes [Footnote of those that stood on the top of the holy house]
with sharp points; they were fixed into lead, to prevent the birds from
sitting there, and defiling the holy house; for such spikes there were
now upon it, as Josephus himself hath already assured us, B. V. ch. 5.
sect. 6.]
19 (return) [ Reland here takes notice, that these Jews, who had
despised the true Prophet, were deservedly abused and deluded by these
false ones.]
20 (return) [ Whether Josephus means that this star was different from
that comet which lasted a whole year, I cannot certainly determine. His
words most favor their being different one from another.]
21 (return) [ Since Josephus still uses the Syro-Macedonian month
Xanthicus for the Jewish month Nisan, this eighth, or, as Nicephorus
reads it, this ninth of Xanthicus or Nisan was almost a week before the
passover, on the fourteenth; about which time we learn from St.
John that many used to go "out of the country to Jerusalem to purify
themselves," John 11:55, with 12:1; in agreement with Josephus also, B.
V. ch. 3. sect. 1. And it might well be, that in the sight of these this
extraordinary light might appear.]
22 (return) [ This here seems to be the court of the priests.]
23 (return) [ Both Reland and Havercamp in this place alter the natural
punctuation and sense of Josephus, and this contrary to the opinion of
Valesilus and Dr. Hudson, lest Josephus should say that the Jews built
booths or tents within the temple at the feast of tabernacles; which
the later Rabbins will not allow to have been the ancient practice: but
then, since it is expressly told us in Nehemiah, ch. 8:16, that in still
elder times "the Jews made booths in the courts of the house of God"
at that festival, Josephus may well be permitted to say the same.
And indeed the modern Rabbins are of very small authority in all such
matters of remote antiquity.]
24 (return) [ Take Havercamp's note here: "This [says he] is a
remarkable place; and Tertullian truly says in his Apologetic, ch. 16.
p. 162, that the entire religion of the Roman camp almost consisted in
worshipping the ensigns, in swearing by the ensigns, and in preferring
the ensigns before all the [other] gods." See what Havercamp says upon
that place of Tertullian.]
25 (return) [ This declaring Titus imperator by the soldiers, upon such
signal success, and the slaughter of such a vast number of enemies, was
according to the usual practice of the Romans in like cases, as Reland
assures us on this place.]
26 (return) [ The Jews of later times agree with Josephus, that there
were hiding-places or secret chambers about the holy house, as Reland
here informs us, where he thinks he has found these very walls described
by them.]
27 (return) [ Spanheim notes here, that the Romans used to permit the
Jews to collect their sacred tribute, and send it to Jerusalem; of which
we have had abundant evidence in Josephus already on other occasions.]
28 (return) [ This innumerable multitude of Jews that were "sold" by the
Romans was an eminent completion of God's ancient threatening by Moses,
that if they apostatized from the obedience to his laws, they should
be "sold unto their enemies for bond-men and bond-women," Deuteronomy
28;68. See more especially the note on ch. 9. sect. 2. But one thing
is here peculiarly remarkable, that Moses adds, Though they should be
"sold" for slaves, yet "no man should buy them;" i.e. either they should
have none to redeem them from this sale into slavery; or rather, that
the slaves to be sold should be more than were the purchasers for them,
and so they should be sold for little or nothing; which is what Josephus
here affirms to have been the case at this time.]
29 (return) [ What became of these spoils of the temple that escaped the
fire, see Josephus himself hereafter, B. VII. ch. 5. sect. 5, and Reland
de Spoliis Templi, p. 129-138.]
30 (return) [ These various sorts of spices, even more than those four
which Moses prescribed, Exodus 31:34, we see were used in their public
worship under Herod's temple, particularly cinnamon and cassia; which
Reland takes particular notice of, as agreeing with the latter testimony
of the Talmudists.]
31 (return) [ See the several predictions that the Jews, if they became
obstinate in their idolatry and wickedness, should be sent again or sold
into Egypt for their punishment, Deuteronomy 28:68; Jeremiah 44:7; Hosea
8:13; 9:3; 9:4, 5; 2 Samuel 15:10-13; with Authentic Records, Part I. p.
49, 121; and Reland Painest And, tom. II. p. 715.]
32 (return) [ The whole multitude of the Jews that were destroyed during
the entire seven years before this time, in all the countries of and
bordering on Judea, is summed up by Archbishop Usher, from Lipsius, out
of Josephus, at the year of Christ 70, and amounts to 1,337,490. Nor
could there have been that number of Jews in Jerusalem to be destroyed
in this siege, as will be presently set down by Josephus, but that both
Jews and proselytes of justice were just then come up out of the other
countries of Galilee, Samaria, Judea, and Perea and other remoter
regions, to the passover, in vast numbers, and therein cooped up, as in
a prison, by the Roman army, as Josephus himself well observes in this
and the next section, and as is exactly related elsewhere, B. V. ch. 3.
sect. 1 and ch. 13. sect. 7.]
33 (return) [ This number of a company for one paschal lamb, between
ten and twenty, agrees exactly with the number thirteen, at our Savior's
last passover. As to the whole number of the Jews that used to come up
to the passover, and eat of it at Jerusalem, see the note on B. II.
ch. 14. sect. 3. This number ought to be here indeed just ten times the
number of the lambs, or just 2,565,000, by Josephus's own reasoning;
whereas it is, in his present copies, no less than 2,700,000, which last
number is, however, nearest the other number in the place now cited,
which is 3,000,000. But what is here chiefly remarkable is this, that no
foreign nation ever came thus to destroy the Jews at any of their solemn
festivals, from the days of Moses till this time, but came now upon
their apostasy from God, and from obedience to him. Nor is it possible,
in the nature of things, that in any other nation such vast numbers
should be gotten together, and perish in the siege of any one city
whatsoever, as now happened in Jerusalem.]
34 (return) [ This is the proper place for such as have closely
attended to these latter books of the War to peruse, and that with equal
attention, those distinct and plain predictions of Jesus of Nazareth, in
the Gospels thereto relating, as compared with their exact completions
in Josephus's history; upon which completions, as Dr. Whitby well
observes, Annot. on Matthew 24:2, no small part of the evidence for the
truth of the Christian religion does depend; and as I have step by
step compared them together in my Literal Accomplishment of Scripture
Prophecies. The reader is to observe further, that the true reason why I
have so seldom taken notice of those completions in the course of these
notes, notwithstanding their being so very remarkable, and frequently
so very obvious, is this, that I had entirely prevented myself in that
treatise beforehand; to which therefore I must here, once for all,
seriously refer every inquisitive reader. Besides these five here
enumerated, who had taken Jerusalem of old, Josephus, upon further
recollection, reckons a sixth, Antiq. B. XII. ch. 1. sect. 1, who should
have been here inserted in the second place; I mean Ptolemy, the son of
Lagus.]
35 (return) [ Why the great Bochart should say, [De Phoenic. Colon.
B. II. ch. iv.,] that "there are in this clause of Josephus as many
mistakes as words," I do by no means understand. Josephus thought
Melchisedek first built, or rather rebuilt and adorned, this city, and
that it was then called Salem, as Psalm 76:2; afterwards came to be
called Jerusalem; and that Melchisedek, being a priest as well as a
king, built to the true God therein a temple, or place for public Divine
worship and sacrifice; all which things may be very true for aught we
know to the contrary. And for the word, or temple, as if it must needs
belong to the great temple built by Solomon long afterward, Josephus
himself uses, for the small tabernacle of Moses, Antiq. B. III. ch. 6.
sect. 4; see also Antiq. B. lit. ch. 6. sect. 1; as he here presently
uses, for a large and splendid synagogue of the Jews at Antioch, B. VII.
ch. 3. sect. 3.]
Developer update: Our Apple and Android apps are coming soon. In the meantime, you can install The Apologetics Network on your phone or computer right now.
Welcome to The Apologetics Network
Welcome to The Apologetics Network, an educational platform dedicated to Christian apologetics, biblical studies, comparative religion, theology, philosophy, and historical research.
The information provided on this website is intended for educational, informational, and research purposes.
Content may include theological interpretations, historical arguments, religious comparisons, artificial intelligence-generated explanations, and differing religious viewpoints.
We encourage visitors to independently evaluate information, examine original sources, and approach religious discussions with intellectual honesty and respect.
AI-generated content may contain inaccuracies, omissions, or interpretations requiring independent verification.
By continuing, you acknowledge the educational nature of this platform and agree to comply with our Terms and Conditions and applicable responsible-use standards.
“Continue browsing” records nothing; we’ll ask again next visit.