INTRODUCTORY NOTICE.
The epistles ascribed to Ignatius have given rise to more controversy
than any other documents connected with the primitive church. As is
evident to every reader on the very first glance at these writings, they
contain numerous statements which bear on points of ecclesiastical order
that have long divided the Christian world; and a strong temptation has
thus been felt to allow some amount of prepossession to enter into the
discussion of their authenticity or spuriousness. At the same time, this
question has furnished a noble field for the display of learning and
acuteness, and has, in the various forms under which it has been
debated, given rise to not a few works of the very highest ability and
scholarship. We shall present such an outline of the controversy as may
enable the reader to understand its position at the present day.
There are, in all, fifteen epistles which bear the name of Ignatius.
These are the following: One to the Virgin Mary, two to the Apostle
John, one to Mary of Cassobelæ, one to the Tarsians, one to the
Antiochians, one to Hero, a deacon of Antioch, one to the Philippians;
one to the Ephesians, one to the Magnesians, one to the Trallians, one
to the Romans, one to the Philadelphians, one to the Smyrnæans, and one
to Polycarp. The first three exist only in Latin: all the rest are
extant also in Greek.
It is now the universal opinion of critics, that the first eight of
these professedly Ignatian letters are spurious. They bear in themselves
indubitable proofs of being the production of a later age than that in
which Ignatius lived. Neither Eusebius nor Jerome makes the least
reference to them; and they are now by common consent set aside as
forgeries, which were at various dates, and to serve special purposes,
put forth under the name of the celebrated bishop of Antioch.
But after the question has been thus simplified, it still remains
sufficiently complex. Of the seven epistles which are acknowledged by
Eusebius (_Hist. Eccl._ iii. 36), we possess two Greek recensions, a
shorter and a longer. It is plain that one or other of these exhibits a
corrupt text, and scholars have for the most part agreed to accept the
shorter form as representing the genuine letters of Ignatius. This was
the opinion generally acquiesced in, from the time when critical
editions of these epistles began to be issued, down to our own day.
Criticism, indeed, fluctuated a good deal as to which epistles should be
accepted and which rejected. Archp. Usher (1644), Isaac Vossius (1646),
J. B. Cotelerius (1672), Dr T. Smith (1709), and others, edited the
writings ascribed to Ignatius in forms differing very considerably as to
the order in which they were arranged, and the degree of authority
assigned them, until at length, from about the beginning of the
eighteenth century, the seven Greek epistles of which a translation is
here given, came to be generally accepted in their _shorter_ form as the
genuine writings of Ignatius.
Before this date, however, there had not been wanting some who refused
to acknowledge the authenticity of these epistles in either of the
recensions in which they were then known to exist. By far the most
learned and elaborate work maintaining this position was that of Daillé
(or Dallæus), published in 1666. This drew forth in reply the celebrated
_Vindiciæ_ of Bishop Pearson, which appeared in 1672. It was generally
supposed that this latter work had established on an immoveable
foundation the genuineness of the shorter form of the Ignatian epistles;
and, as we have stated above, this was the conclusion almost universally
accepted down to our own day. The only considerable exception to this
concurrence was presented by Whiston, who laboured to maintain in his
_Primitive Christianity Revived_ (1711) the superior claims of the
longer recension of the epistles, apparently influenced in doing so by
the support which he thought they furnished to the kind of Arianism
which he had adopted.
But although the shorter form of the Ignatian letters had been generally
accepted in preference to the longer, there was still a pretty prevalent
opinion among scholars, that even it could not be regarded as absolutely
free from interpolations, or as of undoubted authenticity. Thus said
Lardner, in his _Credibility of the Gospel History_ (1743): “I have
carefully compared the two editions, and am very well satisfied, upon
that comparison, that the larger are an interpolation of the smaller,
and not the smaller an epitome or abridgment of the larger.... But
whether the smaller themselves are the genuine writings of Ignatius,
bishop of Antioch, is a question that has been much disputed, and has
employed the pens of the ablest critics. And whatever positiveness some
may have shown on either side, I must own I have found it a very
difficult question.”
This expression of uncertainty was repeated in substance by Jortin
(1751), Mosheim (1755), Griesbach (1768), Rosenmüller (1795), Neander
(1826), and many others; some going so far as to deny that we have any
authentic remains of Ignatius at all, while others, though admitting the
seven shorter letters as being probably his, yet strongly suspected that
they were not free from interpolation. Upon the whole, however, the
shorter recension was, until recently, accepted without much opposition,
and chiefly in dependence on the work of Bishop Pearson above mentioned,
as exhibiting the genuine form of the epistles of Ignatius.
But a totally different aspect was given to the question by the
discovery of a Syriac version of three of these epistles among the MSS.
procured from the monastery of St Mary Deipara, in the desert of Nitria,
in Egypt. In the years 1838, 1839, and again in 1842, Archdeacon Tattam
visited that monastery, and succeeded in obtaining for the English
Government a vast number of ancient Syriac manuscripts. On these being
deposited in the British Museum, the late Dr Cureton, who then had
charge of the Syriac department, discovered among them, first, the
Epistle to Polycarp, and then again, the same epistle, with those to the
Ephesians and to the Romans, in two other volumes of manuscripts.
As the result of this discovery, Cureton published in 1845 a work,
entitled, _The Ancient Syriac Version of the Epistles of St Ignatius to
St Polycarp, the Ephesians, and the Romans_, etc., in which he argued
that these epistles represented more accurately than any formerly
published what Ignatius had actually written. This, of course, opened up
the controversy afresh. While some accepted the views of Cureton, others
very strenuously opposed them. Among the former was the late Chev.
Bunsen; among the latter, an anonymous writer in the _English Review_,
and Dr Hefele, in his third edition of the _Apostolic Fathers_. In reply
to those who had controverted his arguments, Cureton published his
_Vindicæ Ignatianæ_ in 1846, and his _Corpus Ignatianum_ in 1849. He
begins his introduction to the last-named work with the following
sentences: “Exactly three centuries and a half intervened between the
time when three epistles in Latin, attributed to St Ignatius, first
issued from the press, and the publication in 1845 of three letters in
Syriac bearing the name of the same apostolic writer. Very few years
passed before the former were almost universally regarded as false and
spurious; and it seems not improbable that scarcely a longer period will
elapse before the latter be almost as generally acknowledged and
received as the only true and genuine letters of the venerable bishop of
Antioch that have either come down to our times, or were ever known in
the earliest ages of the Christian church.”
Had the somewhat sanguine hope thus expressed been realized, it would
have been unnecessary for us to present to the English reader more than
a translation of these three Syriac epistles. But the Ignatian
controversy is not yet settled. There are still those who hold that the
balance of argument is in favour of the shorter Greek, as against these
Syriac epistles. They regard the latter as an epitome of the former, and
think the harshness which, according to them, exists in the sequence of
thoughts and sentences, clearly shows that this is the case. We have
therefore given all the forms of the Ignatian letters which have the
least claim on our attention.[742] The reader may judge, by comparison
for himself, which of these is to be accepted as genuine, supposing him
disposed to admit the claims of any one of them. We content ourselves
with laying the materials for judgment before him, and with referring to
the above-named works, in which he will find the whole subject
discussed.
As to the personal history of Ignatius, almost nothing is known. The
principal source of information regarding him is found in the account of
his martyrdom, to which the reader is referred. Polycarp alludes to him
in his Epistle to the Philippians (chap. ix.), and also to his letters
(chap. xiii.). Irenæus quotes a passage from his Epistle to the Romans
(_Adv. Hær._ v. 28; _Epist. ad Rom._ chap. iv.), without, however,
naming him. Origen twice refers to him, first in the preface to his
Comm. on the Song of Solomon, where he quotes a passage from the Epistle
of Ignatius to the Romans, and again in his sixth homily on St Luke,
where he quotes from the Epistle to the Ephesians, both times naming the
author. It is unnecessary to give later references.
Supposing the letters of Ignatius and the account of his martyrdom to be
authentic, we learn from them that he voluntarily presented himself
before Trajan at Antioch, the seat of his bishopric, when that prince
was on his _first_ expedition against the Parthians and Armenians (A.D.
107); and on professing himself a Christian, was condemned to the wild
beasts. After a long and dangerous voyage he came to Smyrna, of which
Polycarp was bishop, and thence wrote his four epistles to the
Ephesians, the Magnesians, the Trallians, and the Romans. From Smyrna he
came to Troas, and tarrying there a few days, he wrote to the
Philadelphians, the Smyrnæans, and Polycarp. He then came on to
Neapolis, and passed through the whole of Macedonia. Finding a ship at
Dyrrachium in Epirus about to sail into Italy, he embarked, and crossing
the Adriatic, was brought to Rome, where he perished on the 20th of
December 107, or, as some think, who deny a twofold expedition of Trajan
against the Parthians, on the same day of the year A.D. 116.
Footnote 742:
The other epistles, bearing the name of Ignatius, will be found in the
Appendix; so that the English reader possesses in this volume a
complete collection of the Ignatian letters.
Transcriber’s Note:
The following letters were originally printed side-by-side, the Shorter
form to the left and the Longer to the right. They are transcribed in
this e-book one after another so as to be readable on modern reading
devices, which often cannot handle multiple columns.
Developer update: Our Apple and Android apps are coming soon. In the meantime, you can install The Apologetics Network on your phone or computer right now.
Welcome to The Apologetics Network
Welcome to The Apologetics Network, an educational platform dedicated to Christian apologetics, biblical studies, comparative religion, theology, philosophy, and historical research.
The information provided on this website is intended for educational, informational, and research purposes.
Content may include theological interpretations, historical arguments, religious comparisons, artificial intelligence-generated explanations, and differing religious viewpoints.
We encourage visitors to independently evaluate information, examine original sources, and approach religious discussions with intellectual honesty and respect.
AI-generated content may contain inaccuracies, omissions, or interpretations requiring independent verification.
By continuing, you acknowledge the educational nature of this platform and agree to comply with our Terms and Conditions and applicable responsible-use standards.
“Continue browsing” records nothing; we’ll ask again next visit.